Palmetto Publishing reviews (2026): what authors praise and complain about
Palmetto Publishing is a real, well-rated company: its Trustpilot rating is 4.8 out of 5 (Excellent) from about 1,000 reviews. Trustpilot shows that the company invites every customer to review and has replied to 100% of negative reviews. The 24 most recent reviews were 22 five-star, one four-star and one one-star. Below is what the minority of unhappy authors report (20 one- and two-star reviews we logged, with dates and links to the source), and what to ask any publisher before you sign.
The overall rating, on the day we read it
Trustpilot
4.8 out of 5 · “Excellent” · about 1,000 reviews on Trustpilot
Read on 15 October 2026. We read the 20 most recent one- and two-star reviews (January 2024 to October 2026): 8 × 2★, 12 × 1★.
Trustpilot shows that the company invites every customer to review and has replied to 100% of negative reviews. The 24 most recent reviews were 22 five-star, one four-star and one one-star.
What authors praise
Palmetto is well rated by its own customers: 4.8 out of 5, "Excellent", from about 1,000 reviews on Trustpilot. Trustpilot shows that the company invites every customer to review and has replied to 100% of negative reviews. The 24 most recent reviews were 22 five-star, one four-star and one one-star. We have not logged individual praise reviews yet; this is the rating as Trustpilot showed it on 15 October 2026.
What authors complain about
Reviewers report the following, counted from the 20 one- and two-star reviews we logged. Each line links to the source.
Service after the sale (4 reviews)
- Project lead went on leave and the handover did not happen (1★, March 2026, Trustpilot)
- Excitement at the start turned to disappointment with how the project was handled (2★, February 2026, Trustpilot)
- Work was done, but only heard back when the author emailed (2★, September 2025, Trustpilot)
- Middle-of-the-road experience: some follow-through, some gaps (2★, September 2025, Trustpilot)
Process not explained (4 reviews)
- Paid nearly $4000 and says what was delivered did not match what was promised (1★, April 2026, Trustpilot)
- Spouse of author calls it a pay-to-publish vanity press (1★, March 2026, Trustpilot)
- Says it markets itself as author-centric but works as pay-to-play (1★, March 2026, Trustpilot)
- Says it is paid assistance rather than a publisher (1★, October 2025, Trustpilot)
Marketing that did not deliver (3 reviews)
- Says marketing costs extra and corrections took repeated rounds (1★, October 2026, Trustpilot)
- Reports a today-only sales deadline and walked away (1★, June 2025, Trustpilot)
- Paid several thousand to print and market; disappointed with results (2★, April 2024, Trustpilot)
Print and proof errors (2 reviews)
- Typos printed in the finished book (1★, October 2025, Trustpilot)
- Many back-and-forth rounds to fix the same interior problem (1★, January 2024, Trustpilot)
Other or unclear (2 reviews)
- Published in 2021; mixed experience (2★, July 2025, Trustpilot)
- Long negative account; no single clear theme (1★, February 2024, Trustpilot)
Editing quality (1 review)
- Friendly staff, but timelines missed and author caught errors they missed (2★, June 2026, Trustpilot)
Royalties and sales reporting (1 review)
- No direct visibility of distribution; royalties lower than expected (2★, July 2026, Trustpilot)
Timeline and delays (1 review)
- Good start, but the editor repeatedly missed deadlines (2★, June 2026, Trustpilot)
Refunds (1 review)
- Paid but never used the services and could not get a refund (1★, June 2026, Trustpilot)
Price (1 review)
- Prices too high for disabled or low-income authors (1★, August 2025, Trustpilot)
Questions to ask any publisher before you sign
- Is this a publisher that pays you, or a paid service? Ask for the full price in writing, what it covers, and whether anything continues after the first fee.
- Who will be the publisher of record, and whose name is the ISBN registered in?
- Who is your point of contact, and what happens to your project if that person leaves or is away?
- What exactly is in the marketing, and what is delivered by when? Ask for a list of work, not a promise of results.
- Can you see your sales yourself? Who reports them, who pays you, and how often?
- Do you approve a proof before printing, and what happens if the printed book does not match it?
- If you cannot go ahead after paying, what is the refund position? Ask before you pay.
How we handle each of these
We are a competing publisher, so weigh this accordingly. These are the points above where our own pages already say what we do:
- Royalties and sales reporting. You publish on your own Amazon KDP account, so Amazon reports and pays you directly, and you can check every sale yourself. Our packages: 100% royalties and all rights stay with you
- Print and proof errors. You approve everything before anything is printed, and nothing is reprinted without your written authorisation. How payment works, on our cost page
- If printed copies arrive damaged or defective. If printed copies arrive damaged or defective because of our error, we reprint or replace the affected copies at no additional cost. Our refund policy says exactly when, and what is not covered. Our refund policy
- Process not explained. Our packages are listed with their prices before you talk to anyone. It is pay-for-service self-publishing, and we say so plainly: you keep 100% of your royalties and all your rights. What it costs to publish a book
- Marketing that did not deliver. We make no sales promises: no marketing service can promise sales or bestseller status. Each package lists the work it includes. Our marketing services, and what each package includes
How this was researched
- We read the reviews of Palmetto Publishing on Trustpilot on 15 October 2026, and logged each review we used: its stars, its date and a theme, with a short paraphrase in our own words.
- A quotation, where we use one, is under 15 words, in quotation marks and linked. We do not edit reviews, write them, or ask for them to be written.
- Sources read so far: Trustpilot. We will add others and update this page, and the date above.
- We describe what reviewers report; we do not claim it is true of every author, and we have not tested the company's service ourselves.
If anything here is out of date, tell us and we'll correct it.
Frequently asked questions
Is Palmetto Publishing legit?
Yes, it is a real company with a strong public rating: 4.8 out of 5 on Trustpilot from about 1,000 reviews (read on 15 October 2026). Trustpilot shows that the company invites every customer to review and has replied to 100% of negative reviews. The 24 most recent reviews were 22 five-star, one four-star and one one-star. Some authors report problems, listed on this page with dates and links.
What do authors praise about Palmetto Publishing?
Trustpilot shows that the company invites every customer to review and has replied to 100% of negative reviews. The 24 most recent reviews were 22 five-star, one four-star and one one-star. Trustpilot shows a excellent rating of 4.8 out of 5.
What do the unhappy authors complain about?
Among the 20 one- and two-star reviews we logged, the themes reviewers report most are service after the sale (4), process not explained (4), marketing that did not deliver (3). These are a small minority of the reviews; each is listed above with its date and a link to the source.
Does Palmetto Publishing invite reviews on Trustpilot?
Yes. Trustpilot shows that the company invites every customer to review, so the rating reflects customers who were asked, not only those who chose to write.
How is Harmony Publishing different?
We are a competing publisher, so weigh this accordingly. What we can point to: you publish on your own Amazon KDP account and keep 100% of your royalties and rights, our packages are listed with prices before you talk to anyone, you approve everything before it is printed, and we make no sales promises about marketing. Each is linked on this page.