How to evaluate a publishing offer before signing
Updated November 8, 2026 · By the Harmony Publishing Editorial Team
If you are searching for how to spot a vanity press, start with the written offer. Ask what work is included, what you must supply and how you will approve the result. A publishing label or an enthusiastic sales call cannot answer those questions for you.
Ask the company to explain the arrangement
Ask whether you are being offered a publishing contract, buying defined services or using a platform where you do the work yourself. Ask who performs each stage and what remains your responsibility. Paid assistance can be useful; it needs a clear description so you can judge whether it suits your book.
Keep the proposal and the messages that explain it. If a call changes the scope, ask for an updated written offer before deciding.
Turn broad promises into a list of deliverables
- Editing: which stage of editing, which returned files and which correction rounds? Our editing-stage guide explains the terms.
- Design: what cover and interior work is included, and how will you review it?
- Proofs: when will you see the finished pages, how do you request corrections and what counts as final approval?
- Distribution: which listings or order channels will be set up? Ask separately about availability to order and shop stocking.
- Marketing: which assets or activities will be delivered, when and with what report? A promise of success does not describe the work.
Ask what is excluded and what happens if your manuscript needs work beyond the agreed scope. Record the answer alongside the deliverables so there is one reference for the project.
Clarify approvals, files and communication
Ask who to contact during production and after publication, how progress updates work and what you need to provide before the next stage can start. Ask which dates are estimates and which depend on your feedback.
Request a handover list: the final manuscript, print-ready interior, cover and any ebook files included in the work. Ask whether editable source files are included. Do not assume a preview PDF is the same as an editable design file.
Ask how author accounts, ISBN details and retailer listings will be managed and which records you will receive. If a term about rights or leaving the arrangement is unclear, get it explained before signing; this checklist does not interpret a contract.
Send one written request before deciding
A message you can adapt
Hello [team], Before I decide about [book title / proposal], please confirm the included deliverables, exclusions, review rounds and files I will receive. Please also explain the proof approval process, expected milestones, my responsibilities, the contact route after publication and the specific distribution and marketing work included. Please send an updated proposal covering these points so I can review the full offer together. Thank you, [author name]
Pause if important answers stay vague or if you are pushed to decide before you can review them. Read independent feedback for specific experiences, including praise and company responses. One review does not establish what will happen to your project.
Apply the same questions to Harmony
Read our Author Charter and ask our team to clarify the scope for your manuscript. Our team handles your book from manuscript to print. You check and approve a proof before we print. If the printed books don't match the proof you approved, we reprint them at our cost. Errors that were in the approved proof are not covered.
Contact our team with your book's stage and the work you need. If you already have a project underway, use our status-request checklist or editing corrections guide.
Considering a different publishing service?
Use our republishing preparation guide to organise publication records, rights and ISBN questions, file handover and the sequence of steps before arranging new production.
Frequently asked questions
How do I spot a vanity press before signing?
Look beyond the label and ask what the company will deliver, what the author must do and which terms apply. Pause if the answers are vague, if you are pressured to decide immediately or if promised results replace a written scope. A paid service alone does not establish poor quality.
Does paying for publishing mean something is wrong?
No. Authors can choose paid editing, design and publishing assistance. The important questions are whether the arrangement is explained clearly, the work meets your needs and the written offer matches what you were told.
What should an editing offer explain?
Ask which kind of edit is included, what file you will receive, how you review changes and which correction rounds are included. Ask separately about proofreading the typeset pages.
Does distribution mean my book will be stocked in shops?
Ask the company to distinguish a retailer listing, availability to order and physical shop stocking. Request the actual distribution deliverables in writing instead of assuming these are the same service.
What should I ask about book marketing?
Ask for the specific assets or activities, the schedule, your approval steps and the delivery report. Separate the work being supplied from hoped-for sales, reviews or media coverage.
About this guide
This checklist addresses the process-not-explained theme in the research behind our publisher reviews. Editing terminology and Harmony commitments follow the guides and Author Charter linked above. It describes no individual company and makes no claim about how often problems occur. Harmony provides publishing services, so weigh our guidance accordingly.
If anything here is out of date, tell us and we'll correct it.